On Leaving Fundamentalist Christianity
Wednesday, February 20, 2008
  Addiction Recovery: Can It Be Supernatural?

Around the year 2003, I corresponded with a pastor in Texas. According to what I’d read on his webpage, he had more compassion for emotionally hurt people than most Christians I knew. I liked his ideas, so I wrote to him and ended up doing some Spanish translations for him.

But when I told him that I sometimes received psychological counseling, he hit the roof. Jesus was enough, he said. The Bible, prayer, and Jesus should solve all my problems.

He recommended a method of behaviour modification that included memorizing Colosians, Effesians, and the other Pauline letters. The recovery method, he said, had been successfully used by recovering alcoholics, drug addicts, and sufferers of depression, such as me.

In addition to reading the New Testament compulsively, the individual was to pray a few times a day and to fast every once in a while. That, he assured me, was going to lift my depression.

I was mad when I received his e-mail. Because that’s exactly what I had been doing, so loyally, that I didn’t have time to have fun or to upgrade my skills to keep my career on track. I expressed my disappointment to him, and he ended up apologizing. I never wrote to him again.

In fact, I had started to suspect that reading the Bible was the cause of my ongoing depression. So I stopped cold turkey. Ever since then, I’ve only had a few relapses due to very real difficulties including, of course, the no-small matter of completely leaving the faith.

I was thinking about the Texan Pastor’s behaviour-modification method the other day, and I realized that more than just brainwashing the subject, the technique was aimed at replacing one addiction with another.

If you are always in church praying and reading your Bible, you are less likely to run to your friends and get drunk, or to call your drug dealer to get high, or, in my particular case, to get depressed or angry (BTW, depression is self-directed anger).

To be fair, I have read that, during recovery, that’s exactly what you are supposed to do: get busy, find other interests, find something healthy that tickles your fancy and get involved.

But going back to the Christian technique, its advocates will have me believe that God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit are the ones doing the healing! You are healed, they say, supernaturally. God shows up in your life with all his power and cures your disease.

You don’t say!

Well, that reminds me of a TV show I watched a while ago—can’t remember which. It portrayed a recovery counselor who helped people find their passion. A female patient remembered how much she loved riding horses as a child, and going back to riding helped her dry up and stay sober. According to the Texan pastor’s logic, then, horses have power to heal substance abusers. They’re on par with God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit.

The truth is that recovering from any addiction requires toughness that few have in them. Many say that it has much to do with a person’s sense of self-worth. Others believe that addicts are self-medicated mentally ill individuals.

If we knew the deep causes of substance abuse, perhaps the problem wouldn’t be as huge as it is. Some people do recover and most don’t. All techniques, including religion, have a fairly large rate of relapse. I doubt it that any Jesus method has a greater rate of success than horses do.

And yes, religion is a very serious, destroying addiction. If it weren’t so, this blog—and others of its king—wouldn’t exist. It is pretty tough to recover from having believed in imaginary gods. So anybody who recovers from addictions using Bible God and Jesus is now hooked on another fix that sooner or later will turn on them, unfortunately.

Athinking man wrote an interesting directly related entry on his blog. Find it here.



 
Comments:
Thanks Lorena. I found this really interesting. It resonated so much with what I have felt in the past, and with what was one of the major reasons behind my own de-conversion.

Some of the thoughts I had after reading your post turned into a posting of mine. You may be interested.
 
I read your blog entry, and I have to say, it is nice to read an expert explanation to my ramblings. Thanks!
 
But you're the expert on your life Lorena. I was only rambling in response to your posting. :-)
 
Your idea that religion is an addiction is intriguing. I want to give it more serious consideration, but my initial impression is that I wouldn't be surprised if you're right. I may do a bit more of my "thinking" in a follow-up to my initial comment at Thinking Man's blog.
 
Hi chaplain,

I also hold the "theory" that there is such a thing as an addictive personality. I don't hold the degrees or the research needed to legitimize my observations. But it seems to me that people who lacked love during childhood and who, therefore, lack love for themselves, look for love in all the wrong places: food, alcohol, people, drugs, etc.

I believe those individuals are the ones in danger of becoming addicted to religion. The others, the non-addictive types, are the lukewarm Christians who never get deeply into it.

Just my opinions.
 
I agree with much of what you've written here. You're certainly entitled to your opinions, but it seems to me you might be judging other's faith and/or belief systems too harshly. I appreciate that you had a bad experience with fundamentalist Christianity. I did too. It certainly seems to work for some people though. I think you'll find that open-mindedness and tolerance are essential for good emotional health. Just because the fundamentalist don't practice such things doesn't mean the more enlightened among us shouldn't.

Peace.
 
You're certainly entitled to your opinions

I certainly am, given that this is MY blog.

it seems to me you might be judging other's faith and/or belief systems too harshly.
I think you are the one who is being judgmental of my experience, since well, you haven't walked a mile in my shoes, and obviously, you don't know what I know about the religion and its followers.

It certainly seems to work for some people though.
Sure. It works for people who don't mind believing in lies. This blog isn't here to "preach" to them. It is here to tell those who can't believe that they're not alone in their difficulties with the faith.

I think you'll find that open-mindedness and tolerance are essential for good emotional health.
Really? I could swear that people who believe fantasies and claim to hear voices are MENTALLY ILL.

Just because the fundamentalist don't practice such things doesn't mean the more enlightened among us shouldn't.

Well, it all depends on how you define open-mindness. If you mean to say that believing in an ancient book of fictional stories is being open-minded and enlightened, then I will have to strongly disagree with you. Bible believers are the most close-minded people I know. So, if believing what you believe is being open-minded, then I certainly prefer to be close-minded.
 
Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]



Links to this post:

Create a Link



<< Home
In 2005, I finally decided to listen to my rational self and conceded that Christianity was flawed. I am now an ex-Christian, and I've been writing my thoughts on leaving the faith for a long time. Look at my archives and you will see the progress of my de-conversion from anger and turmoil to self-respect and free thinking.

My Photo
Name: Lorena
Location: British Columbia, Canada


Visit my Friends' Blogs

Archives

January 2006 / February 2006 / March 2006 / April 2006 / May 2006 / June 2006 / July 2006 / August 2006 / September 2006 / October 2006 / November 2006 / December 2006 / January 2007 / February 2007 / March 2007 / April 2007 / May 2007 / June 2007 / July 2007 / August 2007 / September 2007 / October 2007 / November 2007 / December 2007 / January 2008 / February 2008 / March 2008 / April 2008 / May 2008 / June 2008 / July 2008 /


Powered by Blogger

site hit counter

Subscribe to
Posts [Atom]